What you are really choosing between
Editing experience
Speed and Core Web Vitals
Security and maintenance
Plugins versus custom code
Hosting and cost over time
Who should pick which
- Several people publish often and want to arrange pages themselves.
- The needs are standard: a blog, a brochure site, a portfolio, a shop with a normal checkout.
- Nobody technical is on call, and a managed host or maintenance plan will handle updates.
- The team already knows the admin.
- Speed and a distinctive design are part of how the business sells.
- The site has to integrate with your own systems or do something no plugin does.
- Content changes are structured and infrequent, and editors are happy with a focused CMS.
- A developer owns the code, now and in two years.