What a template really is, and what custom really is
Cost: the sticker price versus the real price
Speed: launching next week versus launching right
Differentiation: when looking like everyone else is fine
Maintenance: who keeps the site alive
Ownership: can you take it with you?
When a template is the right call
- You need a site this month and the budget is small.
- The site is a business card: who you are, what you do, opening hours, a phone number and a map.
- You are validating a new idea and might change the whole offer in six months.
- You sell standard products in standard ways, and a Shopify theme already does what your shop needs.
- Nobody in the company will ever touch the site, and a subscription that makes maintenance disappear is worth more to you than owning the code.
When a custom website is the right call
- The website is your main acquisition channel, so a better conversion rate pays for the build many times over.
- Your offer does not fit a theme: configurators, booking flows, quote forms with real logic, member areas or an admin for your own data.
- You need to rank for many services, regions or languages, which takes a real content model and correct hreflang.
- Your brand is the product, and a tasteful template would erase it.
- You need integrations with a CRM, payments, a booking system or internal tools.
- You have outgrown a template site. The second website is very often the custom one.